The Bucket Budget: A Simplistic Approach to Budgeting
Wed, Oct 21, 2009
Earlier this year I posted about the bucket budget I read about it in Money magazine. Essentially, the bucket budget is for all those people who don’t like to budget. It’s an easier and more simplistic style to budgeting that can help with overspending and saving.
Recap of the Bucket Budget
To recap, you set up three separate accounts (two checking and one savings) to manage your cash flow. One account is for fixed expenses, the second for variable expenses, and the third account is for savings. Each week spend money out of the variable account for entertainment, groceries, etc. Pay bills from the fixed expense account and save with the savings account with an automatic transfer when your pay check is deposited. For more details about how it works and rules, click here.
Personally, I like to see the monthly budget broken up into more categories versus these three areas, but I completely recognize that even 8-10 categories, for example, may be more than what some people want to manage when setting up a budget.
That’s why I’m embracing this approach. We’re all different and if this helps someone avoid using a credit card recklessly and overspending each month, I support it.
Beyond the rules and approach to the bucket budget, I’ve thought of a few ideas which I think can make this system perform even better. If I were going to set up a bucket budget today these are the additional steps I would take to insure its success!
Bucket Budget Tips
Leverage software versus setting up an extra checking account
Use Mvelopes Personal or other personal finance software versus setting up separate checking accounts for fixed and variable spending. With Mvelopes in particular you can set up two separate envelopes (variable and fixed) and automatically allocate your paycheck to each envelope when it’s deposited into your account and downloaded to Mvelopes.
Keep an eye on a few variable spending areas
Mange a few common problematic areas in the variable expense envelope that can lead to overspending. Set up sub envelopes under your variable expense envelope for three categories of spending: groceries, entertainment and clothes. All other variable spending can stay in the parent variable spending envelope. Separating spending in these three areas will help you keep a closer eye on spending and avoid depleting the variable envelope too quickly.
Use a high yield online savings account
Set up a savings account, but use an online bank account such as ING Direct Orange savings account. I’ve recently set up my savings with the Orange savings account and have found it provides an extra layer, in a good way, between me and my money. It takes longer to transfer it into my checking account than it would with a savings account from the same financial institution as my checking account. This helps me think twice about using my savings for things it shouldn’t be used for.
How long will it take you to take these three additional steps?
One of the concerns for some people when it comes to budgeting is the amount of time it takes to set up a budget and then maintain it. If this is you, check out the below estimates which might change your thinking.
- Set up Mvelopes: 15 – 20 minutes to sign up, set up your envelopes and enter your financial institutions for automatic download of transactions.
- Set up ING Savings Account: 15 – 20 minutes set up time and 2 – 3 days for account activation.
How long will it take you to maintain your spending each day with the Bucket Budget approach and these tips?
For all the envelopes mentioned, you might spend 5 minutes per day assigning downloaded transactions to the appropriate envelope and reviewing the balances. Tip: assigning transactions in Mvelopes is easy. After they automatically download from your financial institution you can drag and drop them to the appropriate envelope. I’m sure other programs do the same.
- Total estimated time to invest in cash flow management each week: 25 minutes (5 minutes per day)!
- Total cost: Mvelopes has a free 14 day trial and monthly charges for as low as $7.90 per month (2 year plan)
- ING Direct Orange Savings currently pays you 1.3% interest. Learn more by clicking here.
What are your thoughts on the bucket budget approach and using these tips to further the effectiveness of it?
I thought about doing something like this but ING is not showing me a way to make a second checking account. Maybe you found a way…let us know. I do have multiple savings accounts and use those for the buckets for bills but it sure would be nice to have another checking account with ING.
Lulu´s last blog ..Carnival Of Twenty Something Finances For October 26
Thanks for the question. Related to the bucket budget approach, I recommend opening up one checking account and one savings account. Use software like Mvelopes (with electronic envelopes) to manage the different buckets so you don’t have to maintain a bunch of accounts. Hope that helps!